Rent Control or Housing Construction in NY? Risks of Mamdani’s Plan

Mamdani’s housing plan proposes freezing rents and increasing government intervention.

This matters because it could reduce housing supply and affect both tenants and property owners.

Now, the debate is focused on whether to regulate more or build more housing.

Housing policy is back at the center of debate in New York following proposals by Mayor Zohran Mamdani.

His plans to freeze rents and strengthen regulation have raised concerns among analysts and property owners, who warn about potential negative effects on housing supply and access to rentals in the city.

Mamdani’s Housing Plan Under Scrutiny

According to The Heritage Foundation, Mamdani’s housing plan includes freezing rents, increasing regulations, and raising property taxes.

NY rent control sparks housing debate – PHOTO: Shutterstock

Worth noting: Analysts warn that these measures could force middle-class property owners to sell their buildings, allowing the city to step in as a nonprofit “market actor.”

A critical issue is the existence of approximately 50,000 rent-regulated apartments that remain off the market. The main reason is that the cost of renovating these units exceeds the rent owners are legally allowed to charge.

For example: Renovating a vacant apartment can cost up to $600 per square foot. In a 750-square-foot apartment, this represents about $450,000 just to comply with housing codes, according to a report by the New York Post.

New York’s Housing Crisis and Public Policy Failures

The 2019 Housing Stability and Tenant Protection Act severely limits rent increases, even to cover major repairs. Analysts argue that this regulatory framework discourages investment and reduces housing availability.

New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani, a Democrat, made his debut in office on Thursday after taking office by signing a series of executive orders to address the housing crisis. #ImpactoLatino #NuevaYork #ZohranMamdani #crisis #vivienda pic.twitter.com/fRhs86jadn

— Impacto Latino (@ImpactoLatino) January 2, 2026

From this perspective, the problem is not a market failure, but rather the result of public policies that make it difficult to maintain and renovate properties. The outcome is less supply, deteriorating buildings, and greater pressure on prices.

Rent Control: The Contrast With Massachusetts

The debate intensifies when comparing Mamdani’s approach with that of Massachusetts Governor Maura Healey. Although she shares a progressive vision, Healey rejected rent control and defended building more housing as the main solution.

Healey stated that freezing rents will not solve the crisis and that without new supply, prices will remain high. Analysts highlight that this approach acknowledges the relationship between supply and demand.

Latinos in NY Affected by the Housing Situation

Latino families in New York face direct risks. Fewer available housing units mean more competition for affordable rentals, especially in neighborhoods with a high concentration of Latino workers.

In addition, small Latino property owners could be forced to sell if they cannot cover high renovation costs. This could concentrate ownership and reduce housing options for the community.

What Authorities Say

A federal judge blocked an attempt by Mamdani’s administration to intervene in the sale of thousands of rent-stabilized properties, according to Fox News.

Judge David Jones rejected the city’s strategy, delaying its first direct incursion into the real estate market.

Deputy Mayor for Housing Leila Bozorg stated that the city will continue pushing property owners to make repairs and comply with existing regulations.

You may also like: Mortgage Rates Fall to Their Lowest Level Since 2024: Have Conditions Improved for Buying a Home?

What’s Next for Housing and Rent Control in NY

The future of the plan will depend on judicial and political decisions.

The debate between regulation and construction will continue to shape the direction of housing policy in New York.